I’ve recently blogged about Emacs solutions to handling email. As most of you know by now, I’ve settled on mu/mu4e and have been extraordinarily happy with it. Still, not everyone has the same workflow or likes the same things. Andy C over at yakshaving.co.uk has another solution leveraging Gnus.
He was using mu4e and elfeed like but didn’t like that they each had their own UI that required him to learn different key sequences to do his work. He decided to settle on Gnus for email, RSS, and mailing lists. There were a few problems to get things working well and you should read his post to see how he solved them.
For me, the big advantage of mu/mu4e is the instantaneous search facility. I no longer worry about sorting messages into special folders; I just dump everything into a single folder and use the search function to find what I need. Andy C has pretty much the same workflow—although he stores emails by year—and had to install workarounds to get decent search with Gnus.
Oddly, even though I have often complained about using more than one editor because of muscle memory problems associated with different key sequences, I have no problem keeping the key sequences between mu4e and elfeed, for instance, separate. Even if I did, it’s trivial to rebind them to be the same so I don’t see the advantage to switching to Gnus because of it.
Of course, many people, including our fearless leader John Wiegley, swear by Gnus. It serves their workflows and makes them productive. But that’s a little different from trying to make Gnus look like some other solution. Regardless, Emacs, as I often say, allows us to have it our own way. If you like Gnus but want a decent way to search your emails, perhaps Andy C’s post can help you achieve it. If you don’t have special needs, like Wiegley does, mu4e provides an excellent solution. Emacs can provide whatever works for you.